Elliot Temple misquotes David Deutsch

Feb 06, 2025 · By Dennis Hackethal · Fork · Check another quote

Original text

I also had referee problems. The referee of the paper in which I presented that proof insisted that Turing’s phrase “would naturally be regarded as computable” referred to mathematical naturalness – mathematical intuition – not nature. And so what I had proved wasn’t Turing’s conjecture.
David Deutsch, ‘The Mathematicians’ Misconception’, p. 3, https://web.archive.org/web/20201214194155/http://www.daviddeutsch.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/MathematiciansMisconception.pdf

Quote text

I also had referee problems. The referee of the paper in which I presented that proof insisted that Turing’s phrase “would naturally be regarded as computable” referred to mathematical naturalness – mathematical intuition – not nature. And so what I had proved wasn’t Turing’s conjecture.
Elliot Temple misquoting David Deutsch, https://web.archive.org/web/20240721100248/https://www.curi.us/2477-academic-journals-are-unreasonable#:~:text=uploads%2F2018%2F03%2FMathematiciansMisconception.pdf-,I%20also%20had%20referee%20problems.
Ellipsis used (if any): ‘[...]’
Found 4 issue(s) using regular expression . and Myers algorithm, underlined in wavy red. 
I‧also‧had‧referee‧problems.‧The‧referee‧of‧the‧paper‧in‧which‧I‧presented‧that‧proof‧insisted‧that‧Turing’s‧phrase‧“would‧*naturally*‧be‧regarded‧as‧computable”‧referred‧to‧mathematical‧naturalness‧–‧mathematical‧intuition‧–‧not‧*nature.*‧And‧so‧what‧I‧had‧proved‧wasn’t‧Turing’s‧conjecture.

Explanation

# Part Valid? Explanation
1 
I‧also‧had‧referee‧problems.‧The‧referee‧of‧the‧paper‧in‧which‧I‧presented‧that‧proof‧insisted‧that‧Turing’s‧phrase‧“would‧
2 
*
 × no Deletions must be indicated, eg by ‘[...]’ or [replacement].
3 
naturally
4 
*
 × no Deletions must be indicated, eg by ‘[...]’ or [replacement].
5 
‧be‧regarded‧as‧computable”‧referred‧to‧mathematical‧naturalness‧–‧mathematical‧intuition‧–‧not‧
6 
*
 × no Deletions must be indicated, eg by ‘[...]’ or [replacement].
7 
nature.
8 
*
 × no Deletions must be indicated, eg by ‘[...]’ or [replacement].
9 
‧And‧so‧what‧I‧had‧proved‧wasn’t‧Turing’s‧conjecture.

Notes

Ironically, Temple creates this misquote in the context of his allegation that Deutsch had misquoted Turing in a paper published by the Royal Society.

Embed

Click this button to copy the embed code, then paste it where you want the diff to appear:

Please note
  • This tool is in its beta stage. Expect things to break; proceed with caution.
  • This tool isn't magic. It can only catch errors that can be determined programmatically. But quoting properly is also about accurately reflecting the meaning of the quoted content to the reader. That requires an understanding of the content, which is something this site cannot give you. Quoting properly is still your responsibility.
  • Red markings indicate that something was removed in the quote that was present in the original. Conversely, green markings indicate that something added in the quote that wasn't present in the original. Red and green markings don't necessarily error – improper additions and deletions are underlined in wavy red.
  • When no issues are found, that is NOT a guarantee that a quote is not a misquote.
  • Results are not necessarily in line with your styleguide. For example, for ellipses at the end of a sentence, preceding punctuation may or may not be omitted depending on your style guide. Given the following original...
    Tim had dinner, and he enjoyed it.
    ...the quote below will be marked as incorrect because it omits the comma:
    Tim had dinner [...].
    This quote, however, will pass with zero issues:
    Tim had dinner, [...].
    Whether punctuation can be omitted without breaking the meaning the author of the quoted text intended also depends on context and content, so you need to check yourself.
  • Depending on your styleguide, ‘swallowing’ a linebreak with an ellipsis may not be permissible, but this site does permit it.
  • Formatting, such as italics and bold text, is not yet supported. Consequently, changes in formatting cannot be detected. Use something like markdown syntax – *single asterisks for italics*, **double asterisks for bold text**, etc. – to indicate and detect changes in formatting. Pasting from other websites should convert to this syntax automatically. If your quote adds or omits emphasis, be sure to indicate that in your text (eg by saying 'emphasis added' or 'emphasis removed').